Subject to Change Vol. 2 - Questions Every Accounting Firm Should Address at Insurance Renewal

The gap between what's happening in accounting firms and what insurers can measure says a lot about accountant liability right now. AI adoption is outpacing governance, economic uncertainty is making clients quicker to blame their advisors, and the talent shortage is stretching audit teams thin. Meanwhile, the traditional risks haven't gone anywhere.  Unless carriers modify their traditional underwriting tools to account for a rapidly changing environment, profitability and stable pricing are eventually going to be at risk.

As with most professions, a volatile economy amplifies the risks accountants face. Rate swings, tariff shifts, and general uncertainty lead to more disappointed clients, and disappointed clients are more likely to second-guess the professional who advised them. Here's what I'm watching this year, along with the questions firms should be ready to answer at renewal.

What Are the Firm’s Client Acceptance Processes and When Can Exceptions Be Made?

The FTX situation is a great example.  FTX's former auditor is still working through the fallout, agreeing to pay millions to settle customer claims (pending court approval) and paying fines to the SEC. Most recently, in April 2026, the SEC barred its lead engagement partner from practicing before the Commission, finding he lacked the competence to audit a crypto platform of FTX's size and complexity.  The partner settled without admitting or denying the findings, but the takeaway is still valuable. Know when to decline an engagement.  According to the SEC, concerns were raised internally from the start, and the firm took the engagement anyway. Any firm can find itself in that position with a client outside its core expertise.

How Is the Firm Using AI and How Is It Being Monitored and Controlled?

The risk isn't AI itself. It's AI-assisted work going out the door without adequate human review, and client financial data being fed into tools that haven't been vetted. Insurers are still early in assessing this, and there isn't enough claims data yet to price it precisely. Firms that can demonstrate real governance are becoming a better risk. That means a written AI use policy, staff training, human review before work product leaves the firm, and disclosure of AI use in engagement letters. Firms with all four in place are ahead of most of the market.

Are the Firm's Personnel Properly Trained on Deepfakes and Fraud?

Accounting firms combine two things fraudsters want: the authority to move money and access to sensitive financial data. Deepfake fraud cost documented victims more than $1.28 billion in 2025, according to Resemble AI, including a single $35 million corporate loss. Those are only the losses that were publicly reported, and very little of that activity has shown up in professional liability claims data yet.  The pattern we're seeing is a cloned voice or video call that convinces a controller or partner to approve a wire. Call-back verification on a known number and dual authorization go a long way. It's also worth confirming that cyber and professional liability policies work together, so a claim that's part fraud and part negligence doesn't fall into a gap.

Do the Firm's Tax Professionals Understand New Tax Laws and Advise Clients Properly?

Recent legislation introduced new elections and planning opportunities, and with them, new ways to get things wrong. Remote work continues to drive multi-state and residency errors. And the familiar issues remain: e-file authorization lapses and overreliance on software without independent review.

Is the Firm Adequately Staffed?

As senior professionals retire, there aren't enough experienced people coming up behind them, and competition to hire is fierce, which means thinner oversight on audit and assurance work. It isn't a new trend, but it's getting worse, and it raises the odds on every other risk here. Staff-to-partner ratios, turnover, and training investment tell an underwriter a lot about whether a firm's engagements have outgrown its bench.

What Safeguards Are in Place to Identify Client Theft or Fraud?

Failure to detect fraud or embezzlement is still one of the top reasons accounting firms get sued, and a client bankruptcy is a major red flag. When a business fails, everyone looks for someone from whom to recover. For example, in 2024, the Santa Cruz County, Arizona, treasurer pled guilty to embezzling $38.7 million over a decade. The county then sued the state auditor for missing it, and the auditor countersued, alleging, among other things, that the outside accountant who prepared the county's financial statements negligently failed to detect the fraud. The case is still pending.

Questions Underwriters, Brokers, and Accounting Firms Should Be Ready for at Renewal

  • Do you have a written AI use policy, and does all work product get human review before it goes out?

  • How do you verify wire transfers, and has your team been trained on deepfake and voice-cloning scenarios?

  • How do you evaluate new engagements in specialized or high-risk industries?

  • What are your staff-to-partner ratio and turnover rate, and is your bench keeping pace with engagement complexity?

  • How do you keep your tax staff current on new legislation, and is software-prepared work independently reviewed before filing?

  • What procedures do you use to spot red flags for client theft or embezzlement, and how do you document and escalate what you find?

  • How are your cyber and professional liability coverages coordinated?


The claims data will catch up eventually. Until then, the firms and underwriters asking these questions now will be in a much better position than those waiting for a loss to tell them what to ask.

What risks are you seeing in accounting firms this year?