Subject to Change Vol. 3 - Private Equity Bought the Back Office. Who’s Running Your Law Firm?

Five Governance Checkpoints for Law Firms Considering MSO Deals and Underwriters Analyzing Risk

Our first installment of Subject To Change addressed the hot topic of law firm management services organizations (MSOs) and their inevitable rise. Since that time, we’ve already seen a few more deals surface. But what happens after the deal closes? How can law firms protect themselves and their clients within the structure? Below are five governance checkpoints to have in place when you sign.

The deal is easy to diagram: lawyers own the firm, investors own the back office. But how does that look in the day-to-day practice of law? The starting point is simple. In nearly every state, Rule 5.4 still controls everything: no non-lawyer may own an interest in a law firm, serve as an officer or director, or direct or control a lawyer’s professional judgment. State ethics regulators are moving fast, but deals will inevitably outpace the guidance.

Checkpoint 1: Keep the Keys to the Practice

In keeping with Rule 5.4, the firm should commit to an entity owned solely by lawyers and a management committee made up only of lawyers. Non-lawyers should not be given board seats (even ex officio). Certain firm decisions need to be protected as belonging to the law firm: client intake and conflicts, legal strategy, hiring and paying lawyers and staffing cases. Under no circumstances should trust accounts leave control of the firm. Perhaps most critical from both a regulatory and an optics standpoint, the firm should name an independent ethics partner or general counsel with authority to pause any action that touches professional obligations. This should be augmented with periodic outside ethics audits, a lawyer-led compliance committee and annual independence certification from firm leadership.

Checkpoint 2: Draw Clear Lines Between “Legal” and “Business”

The set-up should make divisions of responsibility clear: the MSO runs technology, vendors, facilities, payroll and back-office finance. The law firm should retain control of conflicts and clearance, keeping in mind that the relationship with the MSO can create new conflicts. The MSO cannot control anything related to lawyer judgment, including case volume, speed to settlement or lawyer staffing ratios tied to revenue. In all likelihood this includes AI tool and usage decisions. The MSO can propose (with law firm approval) things like marketing content, budgets and support staffing. The firm and the MSO should also agree up front how gray-zone disputes will be resolved and who has control of the ultimate decision, keeping in mind that resolution of any professional responsibility disputes should stay with the law firm.

Checkpoint 3: Build Independence into the Management Services Agreement (“MSA”)

As with the initial deal, the MSA should be carefully scrutinized with Rule 5.4 in mind. How the MSO gets paid is the most important consideration and the ultimate goal should be avoiding any appearance of fee sharing. The methodology for payment should be carefully documented and independently analyzed for fair market value. Potential pitfalls can include true-ups based on fee collection or billings, minimums, bonuses, cash sweeps and termination payments. Equally important are exit clauses: what happens if the ownership of the MSO changes? What happens if the MSO becomes overleveraged? What if ethical concerns develop? The MSA should include a plan to transition services, return data and transfer technology licenses. It should also address client protections and transitions should the MSO be sold, recapitalized or experience financial distress.

Checkpoint 4: Follow the Money

Any inquiry into the validity of the relationship is going to start with the money. Client money must always go to the law firm, with the MSO being paid on a fixed schedule that is unrelated to collections. Client funds must be protected and free from lender liens and any other liens against firm receivables. Lawyers should be employed and paid by the law firm alone. Performance metrics should not create any appearance of shaping professional judgment. Lastly, if firm lawyers hold any equity in the MSO, the firm should determine whether client disclosure and consent are required under the Rules of Professional Conduct.

Checkpoint 5: Protect the Files and the Privilege

Client files belong to the law firm, not the MSO, and the MSA should say so expressly. MSO personnel who touch client data should act only as the firm’s agents, at the firm’s direction and on a need-to-know basis – a structure that helps preserve privilege and keeps the firm squarely within its supervisory duties under Rule 5.3. In practice, that means confidentiality agreements and training for every MSO employee with access, role-based permissions and audit logs the firm can review at any time. The firm should keep administrative control of its document management and email systems, and its data should be walled off from any other law firms the MSO serves. The MSO should be barred from using client data for its own purposes, including analytics, AI training, marketing or investor reporting, and any financial reporting to the sponsor or its lenders should be stripped of client-identifying information. Any subpoena or third-party request for client information should go straight to the firm so it can assert privilege, and any data breach should be reported to the firm immediately. And on exit, the firm must be able to retrieve every file and all client data promptly, in a usable format, with no fee dispute standing in the way – and with written certification that the MSO has destroyed any copies it kept.

The Bottom Line

MSO structures are not going away, and neither is Rule 5.4. The firms that come through this period well will be the ones that treat governance as part of the deal itself, not a cleanup project after closing. Each checkpoint asks the same question from a different angle: if a regulator, a client or a court looked behind the structure, would it be clear that lawyers – and only lawyers – are making the decisions that matter? For firms, that means negotiating these protections before signing, while the leverage still exists. For underwriters, the five checkpoints offer a practical framework for separating firms that have truly preserved their independence from those that have simply papered over it. Either way, the rules – and the deals – remain subject to change, and the governance should be built to keep up.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The application of Rule 5.4 and other Rules of Professional Conduct varies by jurisdiction and depends on the specific facts of each arrangement, and the rules and guidance in this area are evolving. Firms and underwriters should consult qualified counsel before entering into, structuring or evaluating any MSO arrangement.