California’s FAIR Plan Needs a New Blueprint

With nearly $4 billion in wildfire losses hitting California’s FAIR plan this year, the state’s “insurer of last resort” filed for a 35.8% average rate hike, its highest in seven years. In reaction, the state has passed a set of reforms giving the insurer new financial firehoses (bonds, state-backed lines) and expanded oversight and coverage.

These are admittedly good steps on the surface, but for brokers, carriers, and property owners alike, the real issue isn’t just short-term liquidity; it’s the structural shock. Capacity continues to exit hard-to-insure markets, and affordability is continually under pressure. You can re-fill the hose, but if the house keeps burning, you need a new blueprint. That blueprint needs to be holistic in its approach to solving the growing insured need and provide adequate solutions that enable the private markets to make sufficient return on risk capital.

At Vivere, our Specialty Property program led by CUO Rachael Dougherty is built on that new blueprint. We’re designing solutions for the markets the traditional carriers are walking away from, using clear underwriting discipline and aligning terms in a way that recognizes the risk-reality (not the risk-illusion). Patching the system won’t hold; re-imagining it will.

We are dedicated to reimagining the underwriting model, and it’s exciting to be doing so at these critical junctures in the market.

How do you see these market dynamics playing out?